Last month, a $500 supporter surprised one yeshiva with a $5,000 upgrade—anecdotal evidence I see time and again that roughly one in five donors in the $250–$1,000 tier can jump 10× when you nurture them.
How much hidden revenue is leaking from your $250-to-$1,000 segment?
Mid-tier gifts typically cover 15–25 % of a million-dollar budget—$150,000 to $250,000.
Without a clear owner or CRM prompts, follow-ups to mid-tier donors stall—and in online campaigns, as many as half of those donors drift away within a year.
New sub-$1,000 donors recruited by campaign ambassadors mask the churn, but the shortfall remains.
- The upside: 1 in 5 donors is poised to upgrade dramatically.
- The danger: 50 % attrition drains six figures from your budget.
After guiding mosdos leaders over the past decade, I’ve seen this pattern everywhere.
Fixing the leak and unlocking these upgrades can transform your bottom line—and it doesn’t require extra staff.
The key is Auto-Personal Touches (APs): messages that sound handcrafted but fire off like clockwork.
Below are the quickest AP wins—start with the lowest lift, then level up. Your mid-tier donors (and your budget) will thank you.
1 | Batch Touches
Group mid-tier donors and tackle one batch at a time.
- Recipe – Friday: call 5 donors. Wednesday: send 10 × 30-second voice notes.
- CRM tip – Tag each donor after contact; the system schedules the next touch automatically.
- Donor-centric line – “Hi [Name], your gift let three teens finish a full week of tutoring—just wanted you to hear that directly.”
Ten touches a week = 520 a year—enough to reach every mid-level donor several times.
2 | Merge Emails
Mass emails feel impersonal; re-typing 100 thank-yous is impossible. Mail-merge bridges the gap.
- Go-to – GMass.co (free up to 50 sends/day) sends from your own Gmail, landing in the Primary tab instead of Promotions.
- Alternatives – YAMM’s or BombBomb if you prefer 30-second video clips.
- Micro-touch – Personalize the greeting plus one data point: “Your generosity covered a day of learning this zman.” One click, hundreds of personal notes.
3 | Outsource Cards
You own the relationship; someone else licks the envelopes.
- Lean path – Low-cost path: A virtual assistant or intern at ≈ $25/hour drafts thank-you cards from templates you provide.—5 minutes becomes 30 seconds.
- Hands-off option: Thankster.com “handwrites” cards and mails them; Zapier can trigger a card automatically each time a new gift posts in your CRM.
- Cost math – A $2 card that wins a $500 renewal donation pays for itself 250× over.
Ready to reclaim hidden dollars?
Block 30 minutes this week and test one tactic with ten donors. Prove the impact for yourself—they’ll feel it, and your budget will too.
Hatzlacha Raba!
Avraham
Copyright © 2025 Avraham Lewis & Co.